Two hands holding a knife against a wooden block while a wooden roller with a sharpening disc is rolled along the edge

Bolster

Own a pull-through sharpener? 5 things it has been doing to your knives.

By Ian Bartram, founder, Pedrada Labs. We used a pull-through sharpener for more than ten years.

Add to cart — $149.99

Free shipping. 30 days to try it.

Bolster Block$149.99Add to cart — $149.99

If you have a pull-through sharpener in a kitchen drawer and a knife you stopped using, this is for you.

We used one for more than ten years. We kept replacing knives, because we thought that was how long a good knife lasts. It was not the knives. Here are the five things we wish someone had told us before we bought another sharpener, or another knife. Under each one is what Bolster does instead.

A walnut sharpening block with a wooden roller standing upright in its round socket

1. A pull-through only sharpens the first half-inch

A pull-through is a notch you drag the knife through. It grips about the first half-inch of the edge it can reach and takes metal off that one spot on every pull. That is why a knife feels sharp for about four slices and then feels like it did before. The rest of the blade never got touched, and the spot that did gets ground down again each time. It is not your technique, and it is not cheap steel.

Instead: the knife lies flat on the block, and the roller carries the disc along the full length of the edge, heel to tip.

2. The angle is set by the block, not by your wrist

Every knife is ground to an angle. Hold it a few degrees off and the edge ends up different from the one the knife was made for. On a stone, you hold that angle by hand through every stroke, and it takes practice. We could not do it either.

Magnets hold the knife against an angled block. There are four angles: 15° for double-bevel Japanese-style knives, 18°, 20° for most European and stainless knives, and 22° for heavier edges.

Instead: you pick the angle for your knife, lay the knife on it, and roll the disc along the edge.

A knife held against the angled side of a wooden block while a roller with a sharpening disc is rolled along the edge

3. Most dull knives are dull in one place, not worn out

The knife you stopped using may not be finished. Most dull knives are dull in one spot, where the old sharpener kept hitting, and the steel next to it is still good. We replaced knives for years because we thought dull meant done. Try the knife you gave up on before you buy another.

One honest limit: Bolster will not fix a bent blade.

Instead: it sharpens the full edge at one angle, so the knife at the back of the drawer gets a second chance.

Add to cart — $149.99

Free shipping. 30 days to try it.

4. The last two discs are the finishing step

Bolster comes with five discs, from 360 grit diamond up to 6000 grit. The first discs cut a fresh edge. The last two, 3000 and 6000 grit, polish it and take off the rough burr the cutting leaves behind. Skip them and the edge is sharp but rough. You work up through the discs one at a time, with lighter pressure each time.

Instead: all five discs are in the box, so the finishing step is not a second purchase.

Five round sharpening discs in steel rims, fanned out from dark diamond grit to white fine ceramic

5. A new knife costs $80 to $150. This costs $149.99, once.

Most people deal with a dull knife by buying another one. The next knife you were going to replace runs $80 to $150, for one knife. A sharpener that works on the knives you already own costs $149.99 one time. It does not sharpen serrated knives.

Instead: you pay once, then sharpen the knives you have.

Add to cart — $149.99

Free shipping. 30 days to try it.

What it costs, and what you get

$149.99, with free shipping. A replacement knife runs $80 to $150. Bolster is $149.99, one time, and it works on the knives you already have.

Try it for 30 days on the knife you stopped using. If you still reach for the old sharpener, send this one back, for any reason. The 30 days start when it arrives, not when you order.

Two-year warranty against defects. If something stops working, we send a replacement. We do not repair.

Orders ship within 1 business day. Allow 7 to 10 days for delivery. Tracking is emailed when it ships.

Questions? Email support@bolsterknives.com. You get an answer inside one business day.

Sometime this week you will pick up a knife and it will crush a tomato again. You can buy another knife, or you can try this on the one you have.

Add to cart — $149.99

Free shipping. 30 days to try it.

P.S. Pick the knife you stopped using and try it first. If you still reach for the old sharpener, send this one back.